Projectile motion: separate horizontal and vertical
Does extra horizontal speed make a ball with the same vertical launch land later?
Run a vertical throw beside a ball given horizontal speed, then compare height, landing time, and horizontal displacement.
Learning goals
- Resolve an angled launch into a horizontal component vx that stays constant and a vertical component vy changed by gravity.
- For equal launch and landing heights with no air resistance, use t = 2vy/g for flight time and R = vx·t for horizontal range.
- Explain that only the vertical velocity component is zero at the top; a ball with horizontal speed still moves sideways.
Before you begin
- Use velocity, time, and displacement units, and calculate velocity × time.
- Know that near Earth, gravity changes vertical velocity by about 9.8 m/s each second, downward.
Projectile-motion experiment
Air resistance is ignored and g = 9.8 m/s². Both balls start together at the same height with equal vertical launch speeds, so their heights match at every instant; horizontal speed changes only the projectile's horizontal position.
One quick model check
Observe, then explain
Work through four steps. Each button moves the interactive model to the matching observation state.
-
Launch ball A vertically. Give ball B the same initial vertical speed, vy = 9.8 m/s, plus vx = 6.0 m/s. Their vertical-position equations match, so their heights match at every instant.
Look for: Choose Same-height comparison, move the time slider, and verify equal height readouts.
-
In this model gravity acts only downward, so ax = 0 and vx stays constant. Changing vx from 6.0 to 12.0 m/s keeps flight time at 2.0 s, while B moves from 12.0 m to 24.0 m horizontally.
Look for: Choose Double horizontal speed and compare flight time and range with the first case.
-
At the top, the condition is vy(t) = 0, not zero total velocity. The base case reaches the top at 1.0 s; ball B still has vx = 6.0 m/s, so it continues rightward.
Look for: Press Jump to top and compare the vertical- and horizontal-velocity readouts and arrows.
-
If vy changes from 9.8 to 4.9 m/s, returning to the same height takes 1.0 s instead of 2.0 s. With vx = 6.0 m/s, range becomes 6.0 m; vx alone does not determine range.
Look for: Choose Lower vertical speed and check both readouts with t = 2vy/g and R = vx·t.
Build an explanation
One motion can be separated by direction
An ideal projectile can be treated as two one-dimensional motions at once: constant horizontal motion and vertical motion with initial speed vy and acceleration −g. They share time t, but a speed in one direction does not rewrite the other direction’s equation.
Why equal height means equal landing time
For a launch and landing at the same height, vertical displacement obeys 0 = vy·t − 1/2gt². Apart from t = 0, flight time is t = 2vy/g. Two balls with the same vy have the same nonzero solution; horizontal speed does not appear in this vertical equation.
Range depends on two things
Horizontal displacement is x = vx·t. With vx = 6.0 m/s and vy = 9.8 m/s, t = 2.0 s, so R = 12.0 m. Changing vx changes range proportionally; changing vy changes time aloft first, then range.
The model needs clear boundaries
These conclusions assume constant near-Earth gravity, equal launch and landing heights, and a two-dimensional model without air resistance. Drag changes velocity; slopes, unequal heights, spin, and wind need different conditions or equations.
Printable worksheet
Understand the concept here, then work independently on the A4 sheets. Practice, calculations and investigation records are included together. Reference answers open only in the parent dialog.
Physics
Projectile motion: separate horizontal and vertical
Does extra horizontal speed make a ball with the same vertical launch land later?
- Balls A and B start together from the same height with vertical launch speed 9.8 m/s; B also has horizontal speed 6.0 m/s. With no drag, which statement is correct?
A. They have equal height at every instant and return to launch height together at 2.0 s. B. B lands later because it follows a longer curve. C. B’s horizontal speed makes it rise higher than A.
- With equal launch and landing heights and vy = 9.8 m/s, how do flight time and horizontal range change when vx changes from 6.0 to 12.0 m/s?
A. Time becomes 4.0 s and range stays 12.0 m. B. Neither time nor range changes. C. Time stays 2.0 s and range changes from 12.0 m to 24.0 m.
- Ball B has vx = 6.0 m/s and vy = 9.8 m/s. Which readout is correct at the top of its path?
A. vy = 0 and vx = 0. B. vy = 0 and vx = 6.0 m/s. C. vy = 9.8 m/s and vx = 0.
- For equal launch and landing heights with vx = 6.0 m/s and vy = 4.9 m/s, what are flight time and horizontal range?
A. 2.0 s and 12.0 m. B. 0.5 s and 3.0 m. C. 1.0 s and 6.0 m.