Recognise when clues are insufficient

Logical thinking · Suggested grades 3

Find two valid schedules and recognise that a unique answer is not yet determined.

Download video
Open Chinese transcript
  1. 上午、中午、下午,各安排一项活动。阅读、画画、跳绳,每项只能安排一次。先看看三条线索。
  2. 画画不在上午,阅读在画画之前,跳绳不在下午。这些线索,能不能确定全部安排呢?
  3. 第一种,上午阅读,中午跳绳,下午画画。三条线索,都符合。
  4. 但上午跳绳,中午阅读,下午画画,也全部符合。两种都可以,所以现在还不能确定唯一安排。
  5. 再补一条:阅读在上午。第二种方案就被排除了,只剩上午阅读、中午跳绳、下午画画。
  6. 遇到线索题,不仅要找一个答案,还要看看有没有别的可能。线索不够,说还不能确定,也是有依据的判断。
Sources for this explanation

Logical thinking

One valid plan does not establish uniqueness. Another valid plan shows that more information is needed.

Worked example

Schedule reading, drawing and skipping once each in morning, noon and afternoon. Drawing is not in the morning, reading is before drawing, and skipping is not in the afternoon.

Reading/skipping/drawing and skipping/reading/drawing both work. Adding reading in the morning leaves only the first.

Try one question

Without the added morning-reading clue, is the schedule uniquely determined?