Reason with three wrong labels

Logical thinking · Suggested grades 3

Use the fact that every label is wrong to eliminate possibilities.

Download video
Open Chinese transcript
  1. 三个不透明盒,一个全是苹果,一个全是橙子,一个两种都有。三个标签全贴错了,不是只错一个。
  2. 先看贴着混合标签的盒。因为这个标签也错,它就不可能是混合,只能装同一种水果。
  3. 这次从里面拿出一个苹果。既然它不是混合,又有苹果,这一盒就只能全是苹果。
  4. 再看贴着全苹果的盒。它不能真是全苹果,也不能是已经找到的那一类。剩下全橙子和混合,它该是哪种呢?
  5. 要先看全橙子标签盒。它不能全橙子,也不能全苹果,所以它是混合。最后,全苹果标签盒才确定是全橙子。
  6. 最后检查,三个标签确实都错。如果只是其中一个错,刚才的推理就不能照搬。条件里的每个字,都要用准确。
Sources for this explanation

Logical thinking

The mixed-labelled box cannot be mixed. Resolve it first, then use the other wrong labels step by step.

Worked example

Three boxes contain only apples, only oranges, or both, one of each kind. All three labels are wrong. An apple is drawn from the mixed-labelled box.

The mixed-labelled box is all apples. The orange-labelled box is neither all oranges nor all apples, so it is mixed. The apple-labelled box is all oranges.

Try one question

What is actually in the box labelled only oranges?