List every way to spend a budget

Logical thinking · Suggested grades 3

Enumerate by apple count, including the allowed zero case.

Download video
Open Chinese transcript
  1. 在这家模拟小店,苹果每个三元,梨每个两元。正好花八元,只买完整水果,某种可以买零个。
  2. 先按苹果数量列。三个苹果就要九元,超过八元。所以苹果只能买零个、一个或两个,这三种都要检查。
  3. 零个苹果时,八元全买梨,可以买四个。这是第一种买法,不能因为没买苹果就漏掉。
  4. 一个苹果后剩五元,没法正好买整数个梨。两个苹果后剩两元,正好买一个梨。所以共有两种买法。
  5. 按零、一、二依次列,每种再检查剩下的钱,才知道有没有遗漏。找到一种,不代表已经找全。
  6. 现在加一条:苹果和梨都要买。刚才两种买法,哪种还能留下?请说说理由。小宝贝到你了
Sources for this explanation

Logical thinking

Bound the apple count, check each case, then filter again if a new condition is added.

Worked example

In a model shop apples cost 3 yuan and pears 2. Spend exactly 8 on whole fruit; buying zero of a kind is allowed. List all purchases.

The solutions are 0 apples and 4 pears, or 2 apples and 1 pear. One apple leaves 5 yuan, which cannot buy a whole number of pears.

Try one question

If both kinds must be bought, which purchase remains?