Chemistry · Courses in this subjectExpandCollapse

Reaction rates: curves and fair comparisons

ChemistrySuggested ages: 14–18

Does a faster reaction necessarily produce more product?

Compare how temperature, concentration, contact surface area and a catalyst change an illustrative reaction curve. Separate speed from yield and calculate average rates from a numerical table.

Learning goals

  • Distinguish more product at a given time from a larger final yield on a volume–time graph.
  • Change one condition at a time and explain which other conditions a fair comparison requires.
  • Calculate average rate as change in volume divided by elapsed time, with units.
  • Explain the boundaries between model parameters, endpoint assumptions and real reactions.

Before you begin

  • Recognise reactants, products and solution concentration, and read a line graph.
  • Calculate differences and ratios. The meaning of limiting reactant is introduced in this lesson.

Reaction-rate comparison bench

Reference: 20 °C, concentration and surface area both 1×, no catalyst. Both samples contain the same amount of limiting reactant, with the other reactant in excess. Gas volumes use the same measurement temperature and pressure.

Fixed referenceCurrent comparison
Product volume (mL) / Time (s)Product gas volume against time: the dashed line is the reference and the solid line is the comparison. The same model values are provided in the table below. 020406080 020406080100120 Product volume (mL)Time (s) Shared limit: 80 mL
Reference product volume
31.5 mL
Comparison product volume
50.6 mL
Comparison average rate from 0 s to the selected time
2.53 mL/s
Curve values (model output, rounded to one decimal place)
Time (s)Fixed reference (mL)Current comparison (mL)
00.00.0
1017.731.5
2031.550.6
4050.669.2
6062.176.0
9071.679.1
12076.079.8
Change one condition at a time

Comparison solution volume, holding the amount of dissolved reactant fixed: 100 mL

One variable differs from the reference, so its effect can be compared.

Teaching model: V(t) = 80 × (1 − exp(−kt)). Here k is an effective teaching parameter for the curve, not a real reaction rate constant. Reference k = 0.025 s⁻¹. Authored multipliers are 2^((T−20)/20) for temperature, c for concentration, √A for surface area, and 2.5 for a catalyst; multiply them to obtain k. These are not experimental fits or universal rate laws. They change how quickly the curve approaches its limit.

Concentration is changed by changing solution volume, so the amount of dissolved reactant and the final yield stay fixed. Increasing the concentration of a limiting reactant at fixed volume could also raise the final yield in a real experiment. Gas loss, side reactions and reversible reactions are not modelled.

One quick model check

1The reference produces 31.5 mL at 20 s and 50.6 mL at 40 s. What is its approximate average rate over 20–40 s?

Observe, then explain

Work through four steps. Each button moves the interactive model to the matching observation state.

  1. The reference is 20 °C and the comparison is 40 °C, with other conditions unchanged. Compare product volumes at 20 s, then inspect the curves at 120 s as they approach the same limit.

    Look for: Record both volumes at 20 s. Explain whether this supports “faster” or “greater final yield”.

  2. Choose the concentration comparison; temperature returns to 20 °C. The amount of dissolved reactant stays fixed, so doubling concentration reduces solution volume from 100 mL to 50 mL. The shared endpoint is a condition of this comparison, not a rule for every concentration experiment.

    Look for: Set concentration to 0.5× and read the solution volume. Explain why concentration, solution volume and dissolved amount cannot all stay unchanged when concentration is varied.

  3. Choose the surface-area comparison. Imagine breaking the same mass of solid into smaller pieces to expose more contact area to the solution. Here “4×” describes relative contact area, not four times the mass or amount of reactant.

    Look for: Compare the 20 s readings at 1× and 4× surface area. State how the mass of solid must be controlled.

  4. Choose the catalyst comparison. Inspect the same-time readings and shared endpoint, then also raise the temperature. The page warns that changing two conditions prevents attributing the difference to a single factor.

    Look for: Explain the difference between a higher rate and a greater total yield, then restore a one-variable comparison.

Build an explanation

First decide what is measured

This lesson uses product gas volume as an indicator of how much product has formed: mL on the vertical axis and seconds on the horizontal axis. Real gas volume also depends on measurement temperature and pressure. A temperature comparison therefore needs volumes corrected to common conditions; thermal expansion alone does not mean more product formed. Common measurement conditions are assumed here. Every value is calculated by the model, not collected experimentally.

What does a steeper curve mean?

Over the same short interval, a larger rise in the curve means faster product formation. The model starts steep and becomes flatter as the limiting reactant is consumed. A limiting reactant is used up first and limits the maximum product amount. Being higher at 20 s describes progress at that time; approaching the same 80 mL limit describes final yield. These are different questions.

Collision explanations have conditions

For many reactions, higher temperature means faster particle motion and a greater fraction of collisions energetic enough to overcome a reaction barrier. Higher concentration typically puts more reacting particles into a given volume; more exposed solid surface typically offers more contact sites. These common explanations do not give a universal speed-up factor. Mechanism, mixing and mass transfer can matter. Real rate laws and rate constants must be determined experimentally.

Why does the concentration comparison keep the same endpoint?

Concentration describes dissolved amount per unit volume; it does not tell us the total amount on its own. This lesson keeps the same amount of dissolved limiting reactant and changes solution volume to 50, 100 or 200 mL, producing relative concentrations of 2, 1 or 0.5. The other reactant remains in excess, so all model endpoints are 80 mL. Raising limiting-reactant concentration at fixed solution volume also increases its amount and may change the final yield. That requires a different model and comparison.

A catalyst changes a pathway rather than adding reactant

A suitable catalyst can provide an alternative reaction pathway with lower activation energy and is regenerated overall. This lesson assumes an effective catalyst, no altered side reactions and a fixed amount of limiting reactant. It therefore speeds progress toward the same yield. A catalyst does not work for every reaction; the 2.5× multiplier here is an authored teaching parameter. Reversible-reaction equilibria, catalyst deactivation and complex mechanisms are outside this model.

Calculate average rate from the table

Average rate equals change in product volume divided by elapsed time. The reference table gives 31.5 mL at 20 s and 50.6 mL at 40 s. The interval average is (50.6 − 31.5) ÷ (40 − 20) = 0.955 mL/s, or 0.96 mL/s to two decimal places. Using 50.6 ÷ 40 answers a different question: the average starting at 0 s. Rounded table values can give slightly different results from the unrounded formula.

Turn an observation into a checkable conclusion

Make a prediction, select one comparison, hold the reading time fixed, then record and explain both values. State the conditions of your conclusion: “In this model, with limiting-reactant amount and other settings fixed, higher temperature gives more product at 20 s but the same endpoint.” Do not turn that statement into a law for every reaction. This is an abstract gas-generating model, not a specified set of real reagents, and its readings cannot determine chemical quantities or guide unsupervised mixing.

Calculation method and worked example

Start with a complete example

The reference model table gives 0.0 mL at 0 s and 17.7 mL at 10 s. How do you find the interval average rate?

  1. Find the volume change: 17.7 − 0.0 = 17.7 mL.
  2. Find elapsed time: 10 − 0 = 10 s.
  3. Divide and include units: 17.7 ÷ 10 = 1.77 mL/s. This is an interval average from model values, not an instantaneous rate or experimental measurement.

The related calculations are in this lesson’s A4 worksheets, ready to download after learning.A4 calculation practice

Printable worksheet

Understand the concept here, then work independently on the A4 sheets. Practice, calculations and investigation records are included together. Reference answers open only in the parent dialog.

Chemistry

Reaction rates: curves and fair comparisons

Name: __________________Date: __________________
Lesson model reference (schematic, not to scale)

Does a faster reaction necessarily produce more product?

  1. The reference produces 31.5 mL at 20 s and 50.6 mL at 40 s. What is its approximate average rate over 20–40 s?

    A. 1.27 mL/s B. 0.96 mL/s C. 19.1 mL/s

  2. With a catalyst, the model has more product at 20 s but still approaches 80 mL. Which explanation fits?

    A. The catalyst increases the amount of limiting reactant. B. A lower final yield always causes a faster reaction. C. Progress is faster, while the endpoint set by the fixed reactant amount is unchanged.

  3. Why does doubling concentration keep the same endpoint in this lesson?

    A. The dissolved amount stays fixed, solution volume halves, and the other reactant remains in excess. B. Changing concentration can never affect final yield. C. Concentration and total amount are the same quantity.

  4. One sample is heated, receives a catalyst and uses smaller solid pieces. Its curve is steeper. How should you isolate the effect of surface area?

    A. Compare only the highest point on each curve. B. Keep temperature, catalyst condition, solid mass and other conditions fixed; change only contact surface area. C. Also quadruple the mass of solid.

Calculation practice and worked example

Reaction rates: curves and fair comparisons

Name: __________________Date: __________________

Start with a complete example

The reference model table gives 0.0 mL at 0 s and 17.7 mL at 10 s. How do you find the interval average rate?

  1. Find the volume change: 17.7 − 0.0 = 17.7 mL.
  2. Find elapsed time: 10 − 0 = 10 s.
  3. Divide and include units: 17.7 ÷ 10 = 1.77 mL/s. This is an interval average from model values, not an instantaneous rate or experimental measurement.

Use new data and calculate independently

  1. Reference model table: 31.5 mL at 20 s and 50.6 mL at 40 s. Calculate the average rate over 20–40 s to two decimal places.

    Show your calculation, unit and reasoning: (mL/s)

  2. Reference model table: 50.6 mL at 40 s and 62.1 mL at 60 s. Calculate the average rate over 40–60 s to two decimal places.

    Show your calculation, unit and reasoning: (mL/s)