Chemistry · Courses in this subjectExpandCollapse

Molecular vibrations: IR and Raman activity

ChemistrySuggested ages: 16–18+

If the atoms are moving, why can a vibration still be IR inactive?

Compare symmetric stretch, antisymmetric stretch, and bending in CO₂ and H₂O, then classify IR and Raman activity from changes at equilibrium.

Learning goals

  • Recognise three schematic normal modes and compare the symmetry of CO₂ and H₂O.
  • Use derivatives of dipole moment and polarizability with respect to a normal coordinate at equilibrium to classify activity.
  • Explain IR–Raman mutual exclusion in centrosymmetric CO₂ and recognise the model’s qualitative limits.

Before you begin

  • Know the basic ideas of bonds, molecular geometry, and dipole moment.
  • Interpret a derivative as a rate of change near equilibrium.

Molecular-vibration spectroscopy lab

CO₂Symmetric stretch
OCO

Equilibrium inversion centre

Dashed: equilibrium position

Δμ component (schematic)
Δα tensor projection (schematic)
Molecule
Mode
Infrared (IR)inactive
Ramanactive
Normalized |∂μ/∂Q|0
Normalized |∂α/∂Q|1
Comparison presets

Activity depends on first derivatives with respect to a normal coordinate at equilibrium, not on a permanent dipole or one snapshot. Δμ and Δα are qualitative component projections; α is a tensor, not an absolute scalar magnitude. Displacements are exaggerated and playback is not a real molecular timescale; values are qualitative normalized 0/1 only. One planar section represents CO₂’s two degenerate perpendicular bends.

One quick model check

1Which activity classification applies to CO₂ symmetric stretch?

Observe, then explain

Work through four steps. Each button moves the interactive model to the matching observation state.

  1. Both O atoms move away from or towards C together. Their dipole changes cancel, so ∂μ/∂Q=0, while polarizability changes: IR inactive and Raman active.

    Look for: Scrub the phase and check the opposite O directions and both activity flags.

  2. The O atoms move in the same direction and C responds to keep the centre of mass fixed. The first-order dipole change is nonzero: IR active and Raman inactive.

    Look for: Select antisymmetric stretch and observe the larger schematic C displacement.

  3. Bending changes the dipole and is IR active; mutual exclusion makes it Raman inactive. Real CO₂ has two degenerate perpendicular bends; the diagram shows one 2D section.

    Look for: Select bending and identify the omitted perpendicular degenerate direction.

  4. H₂O lacks an inversion centre. All three displayed modes change both dipole moment and polarizability, so all are IR and Raman active; activity does not imply equal peak strength.

    Look for: Switch through all three H₂O modes and compare the flags.

Build an explanation

A normal coordinate describes collective motion

A normal mode is not one bond moving alone: all atoms move with fixed relative directions and amplitudes. This model mass-balances displacements to keep the centre of mass fixed.

IR activity tests the dipole derivative

IR activity requires ∂μ/∂Q≠0 at equilibrium. A permanent dipole is not sufficient, and a polar-looking animation frame is not the criterion.

Raman activity tests the polarizability derivative

Raman activity requires ∂α/∂Q≠0 at equilibrium: the ease of distorting the electron cloud changes during the vibration. This differs from dipole change.

Inversion symmetry gives mutual exclusion

In a centrosymmetric molecule, one normal mode cannot be both IR and Raman active. CO₂ follows this rule; bent H₂O lacks an inversion centre and is not constrained by it.

Printable worksheet

Understand the concept here, then work independently on the A4 sheets. Practice, calculations and investigation records are included together. Reference answers open only in the parent dialog.

Chemistry

Molecular vibrations: IR and Raman activity

Name: __________________Date: __________________
Lesson model reference (schematic, not to scale)

If the atoms are moving, why can a vibration still be IR inactive?

  1. Which activity classification applies to CO₂ symmetric stretch?

    A. IR inactive, Raman active B. IR active, Raman inactive C. Both active

  2. What correctly determines IR activity?

    A. Bond length in any one frame B. ∂μ/∂Q at equilibrium C. Whether the molecule has a permanent dipole

  3. Which statement about CO₂ bending is correct?

    A. There is one bend and it is IR inactive B. The animation speed is the molecular speed C. There are two degenerate perpendicular bends; one 2D section is shown

  4. How are the three displayed H₂O modes classified?

    A. All Raman-only B. All both IR and Raman active C. Only bending is active