Disproving a square-sum claim

Logical thinking · Suggested grades 6

Use one valid counterexample to reject an “always” statement.

Download video
Open Chinese transcript
  1. 猜想说两个奇数的平方和一定是四的倍数。“一定”只要遇到一个反例就会被否定。
  2. 选择两个符合前提的奇数一和三。它们确实都是奇数。
  3. 一的平方是一,三的平方是九,平方和是一加九等于十。
  4. 十除以四余二,不是四的倍数,所以结论在这组奇数上失败。
  5. 一个符合前提却不符合结论的例子已经足够否定“所有情况都成立”。
  6. 因此猜想错误。检查几个成功例子不能证明全部,但一个反例能推翻全称说法。
Sources for this explanation

Logical thinking

Choose values satisfying the premise, calculate the conclusion, and show it fails.

Worked example

Claim: the sum of the squares of two odd numbers is always divisible by 4. Is it true?

No. The odd numbers 1 and 3 give 1²+3²=10, which is not divisible by 4.

Try one question

What is one squared plus three squared?