Clockwise order at a round table: rotations match, reflections differ

Logical thinking · Suggested grades 5

Enumerate circular arrangements by fixing one person, treating rotations as identical while keeping reflected orders distinct.

Download video
Open Chinese transcript
  1. 三人围圆桌,本题只看顺时针次序;整体转动算同一种,镜像次序算不同。
  2. 为了消除旋转重复,先固定甲的位置;圆桌转动后总能把甲转回这里。
  3. 剩下乙和丙只有两种顺时针排列:甲乙丙,或者甲丙乙。
  4. 两种互为镜像,但题目明确镜像不同,所以不能把它们合并。
  5. 若从6个线性排列起数,每种圆坐法有3个旋转,六除三也是2。
  6. 答案是2种;是否合并镜像必须由题目先说明,不能自行决定。
Sources for this explanation

Logical thinking

Fix A to remove rotational duplicates, then arrange B and C in the two remaining clockwise orders.

Worked example

A, B and C sit around a round table. Rotations count as the same arrangement, but reflected clockwise orders count as different. How many arrangements are there?

There are 2 arrangements. With A fixed, the clockwise order is either A-B-C or A-C-B, and the stated rule keeps those reflections separate.

Try one question

For four people up to rotation, how many remain to arrange after fixing A?