Testing a median claim with a counterexample
Test an absolute claim about the median by changing one value in a small ordered data set.
The video could not load. Check your connection and try again, or download it directly.
Download video
Open Chinese transcript
- 猜想说:把一组数的最大数增大,中位数一定增大。先用2、4、9检查。
- 原数据从小到大是2、4、9,中间位置的数是4,所以原中位数为4。
- 把最大数9改成20,新数据排序后是2、4、20,中间数仍是4。
- 前后比较,最大数从9变成20,中位数却从4变成4,没有增大。
- 这个例子满足最大数增大的前提,却不满足中位数增大的结论,所以它是否定“一定”的反例。
- 我们只得到“不一定增大”,不能反过来说中位数永远不会变化。
Sources for this explanation
Logical thinking
Sort the data before and after changing the maximum, then compare the number in the middle position.
Worked example
Someone claims that increasing the largest value in a data set must increase the median. Test the claim using 2, 4 and 9.
The claim is false. Changing 9 to 20 gives 2, 4, 20, whose median is still 4, so this example is a counterexample.
Try one question
The middle remains 5.