Two balanced weighings: eliminate the normal objects

Logical thinking · Suggested grades 5

Combine two balance-scale results to identify the one heavy object among four candidates.

Download video
Open Chinese transcript
  1. A、B、C、D里只有一件偏重,另外三件与正常标准物S一样重。
  2. 第一次称A对B,天平平衡;由于不可能两件都偏重,所以A和B都正常。
  3. 第二次称C对S也平衡。S已知正常,因此C也正常。
  4. 四个候选中已经排除A、B、C,唯一没有排除的是D,所以D偏重。
  5. 少看任一次平衡都还会剩多个候选;两次结果必须合起来使用。
  6. 现在换成E、F、G、H:E对F左边低,G对S平衡。请指出偏重物,小宝贝到你了。
Sources for this explanation

Logical thinking

Use the first balance to rule out A and B, then use the known standard S to rule out C.

Worked example

Exactly one of A, B, C and D is heavy; the other three match the normal standard S. A balances B, and C balances S. Which object is heavy?

D is heavy. The first balance shows that A and B are normal, and the second shows that C is normal, leaving only D.

Try one question

At most one of P,Q,R is heavy and all others are normal. P balances Q and R balances normal S. Which can be heavy?