Two balanced weighings: eliminate the normal objects
Combine two balance-scale results to identify the one heavy object among four candidates.
The video could not load. Check your connection and try again, or download it directly.
Download video
Open Chinese transcript
- A、B、C、D里只有一件偏重,另外三件与正常标准物S一样重。
- 第一次称A对B,天平平衡;由于不可能两件都偏重,所以A和B都正常。
- 第二次称C对S也平衡。S已知正常,因此C也正常。
- 四个候选中已经排除A、B、C,唯一没有排除的是D,所以D偏重。
- 少看任一次平衡都还会剩多个候选;两次结果必须合起来使用。
- 现在换成E、F、G、H:E对F左边低,G对S平衡。请指出偏重物,小宝贝到你了。
Sources for this explanation
Logical thinking
Use the first balance to rule out A and B, then use the known standard S to rule out C.
Worked example
Exactly one of A, B, C and D is heavy; the other three match the normal standard S. A balances B, and C balances S. Which object is heavy?
D is heavy. The first balance shows that A and B are normal, and the second shows that C is normal, leaving only D.
Try one question
Both balances eliminate P, Q and R.