Find the heavier bag
Find the heavier bag
The video could not load. Check your connection and try again, or download it directly.
Download video
Open Chinese transcript
- 三袋里恰有一袋更重,另外两袋一样重。一次天平有左重、右重、平衡三种结果。
- 把甲放左盘、乙放右盘,丙留在秤外。若左盘低,按题设甲就是较重袋。
- 若右盘低,同样说明乙比甲重,于是较重袋是乙,未上秤的丙不是答案。
- 若两盘平衡,甲乙就是两袋等重的,没上秤的丙只能是较重袋。
- 三个结果分别对应甲、乙、丙,没有遗漏也没有冲突,所以一次称量足够。
- 现在红、绿、蓝三袋仍是恰一袋重、另两袋等重。图中红袋和绿袋平衡,蓝袋未上秤,请指出较重袋,小宝贝到你了。
Sources for this explanation
Logical thinking
Enumerate the left-heavy, right-heavy and balanced outcomes of one weighing.
Worked example
Exactly one of bags A, B and C is heavier; the other two have equal mass. How can one weighing find it?
Weigh A against B: the lower side is heavier; if balanced, the unweighed bag C is heavier.
Try one question
A and B are equal, so the only heavier bag is C.