Two door signs

Logical thinking · Suggested grades 3

Two door signs

Download video
Open Chinese transcript
  1. 奖品只可能在红门或蓝门。红牌说在红门,蓝牌说不在红门,并且恰有一句真。
  2. 先假设奖品在红门。红牌为真,蓝牌为假,真话数正好是1。
  3. 再假设奖品在蓝门。红牌为假,蓝牌为真,真话数仍然是1。
  4. 两个位置都满足“恰有一句真”,所以这条条件没有排除任何一扇门。
  5. 不能因为先试红门成功就停止;有限枚举要把所有候选都检查完。
  6. 结论是不能确定奖品在哪。需要再增加一条能区分两种情况的新线索。
Sources for this explanation

Logical thinking

Substitute each possible prize location and count true statements.

Worked example

The prize is behind the red or blue door. Red says “behind red”; blue says “not behind red”. Exactly one is true. Can the door be determined?

Red location makes red true and blue false; blue location reverses them. Both satisfy exactly one true statement.

Try one question

Both locations make exactly one statement true. Can the prize location be fixed?