Who lives in the middle?

Logical thinking · Suggested grades 3

Who lives in the middle?

Download video
Open Chinese transcript
  1. 三间房从左到右排列,猫、狗、兔各住一间。线索一:猫不住端点。
  2. 左屋和右屋都是端点,所以猫只能住中间屋。
  3. 线索二说狗不在猫右边。猫已在中间,狗就不能去右屋,只能住左屋。
  4. 剩下的兔没有别的空屋,只能住右屋,得到狗、猫、兔。
  5. 核对:三只各住一屋;猫确实不在端点;狗也不在猫右边。
  6. 现在换成熊、鹿、狐。鹿不住端点,熊不在鹿右边。先锁中间,再排左右,逐条核对,请摆卡并解释,小宝贝到你了。
Sources for this explanation

Logical thinking

Fix the non-end occupant first, then use the left/right clue and check the sole remaining arrangement.

Worked example

Cat, dog and rabbit occupy left, middle and right houses. Cat is not at an end; dog is not right of cat. What is the arrangement?

Cat must be middle; dog cannot be right of cat, so dog is left and rabbit right.

Try one question

Deer is not at an end; bear is not right of deer. Order bear, deer, fox?