Cross-check a table by rows and columns

Logical thinking · Suggested grades 2

This lesson uses a finite model to practise cross-check a table by rows and columns and checks every stated constraint.

Download video
Open Chinese transcript
  1. 先看表格:红队有三个苹果、两个梨,蓝队有四个苹果、一个梨。有人把总计写成十一。
  2. 横着算红队,三加二等于五;蓝队四加一也等于五,两行合起来是十。
  3. 换个方向竖着算,苹果一列是三加四等于七。
  4. 梨一列是二加一等于三,七加三仍然得到十。
  5. 横算和竖算都得到十,四个原始数字各用一次,所以十一是错误总计。
  6. 同一张表从两个方向求和,结果一致才通过核对;正确总计是十,不是题面写的十一,四格都不能漏。
Sources for this explanation

Logical thinking

Record the conditions, apply the finite method, and substitute the result back into the original problem.

Worked example

Red team has 3 apples and 2 pears; blue has 4 apples and 1 pear. Why is total 11 wrong?

Row totals are 5 and 5; column totals are 7 and 3. Both directions give 10, so 11 is an incorrect grand total.

Try one question

A table has rows 2 and 3, then 1 and 4. What is the total?