Test a statement against a picture

Logical thinking · Suggested grades 1

This lesson uses a finite picture to practise test a statement against a picture and verifies every stated condition.

Download video
Open Chinese transcript
  1. 盒子里清楚画着三个红球和一个蓝球。木偶说:“盒里全部是红球。”
  2. “全部”表示每一个球都必须是红色,所以我们要把四个球逐个看完。
  3. 前三个球是红色,但第四个球是蓝色。只要找到这一个蓝球,木偶的话就不能成立。
  4. 蓝球就是反例:它在盒子里,却不是红色,因此“全部是红球”是错误的。
  5. 答案是不对。不是因为红球少,而是因为“全部”不允许出现任何一个蓝球。
  6. 判断“全部”这样的句子时,一个不符合的对象就足以说明句子不成立。
Sources for this explanation

Logical thinking

Record the constraints, apply test a statement against a picture, then check the result against every condition.

Worked example

A box has 3 red balls and 1 blue ball. Is “all balls are red” true?

The claim says every ball is red. The visible blue ball is one counterexample, so the claim is false.

Try one question

A box contains 3 red balls. Is “all are red” true?