Test a statement against a picture
This lesson uses a finite picture to practise test a statement against a picture and verifies every stated condition.
The video could not load. Check your connection and try again, or download it directly.
Download video
Open Chinese transcript
- 盒子里清楚画着三个红球和一个蓝球。木偶说:“盒里全部是红球。”
- “全部”表示每一个球都必须是红色,所以我们要把四个球逐个看完。
- 前三个球是红色,但第四个球是蓝色。只要找到这一个蓝球,木偶的话就不能成立。
- 蓝球就是反例:它在盒子里,却不是红色,因此“全部是红球”是错误的。
- 答案是不对。不是因为红球少,而是因为“全部”不允许出现任何一个蓝球。
- 判断“全部”这样的句子时,一个不符合的对象就足以说明句子不成立。
Sources for this explanation
Logical thinking
Record the constraints, apply test a statement against a picture, then check the result against every condition.
Worked example
A box has 3 red balls and 1 blue ball. Is “all balls are red” true?
The claim says every ball is red. The visible blue ball is one counterexample, so the claim is false.
Try one question
All three balls are red and there is no counterexample, so the statement is true.