Find what stays unchanged when flipping coins

Logical thinking · Suggested grades 6

Check every kind of flip and use parity to decide whether a target can be reached.

Download video
Open Chinese transcript
  1. 五枚双面硬币,开始全是太阳面。每一步必须选两枚不同的硬币,一起翻面。能不能最后,只有一枚月亮面?
  2. 别只试着翻,先看每次会怎样改变。两枚原来都是太阳,翻后都成月亮,月亮数增加二。
  3. 两枚原来都是月亮,翻后都成太阳,月亮数减少二。这是第二种情况。
  4. 如果一枚太阳,一枚月亮,翻后只是交换,月亮的个数不变。两枚硬币的三种组合,已经检查全了。
  5. 开始是零枚月亮。每次加二、减二,或者不变,都保留偶数。所以不管翻多少步,月亮数始终是偶数。
  6. 一是奇数,因此不能只剩一枚月亮。这个结论依靠每次翻两枚的规则。如果允许只翻一枚,答案就变了。
Sources for this explanation

Logical thinking

Flipping two distinct coins changes the moon count by +2, −2 or 0. Starting from zero, it remains even after every move.

Worked example

Five two-sided coins start sun-up. Every move flips exactly two distinct coins. Can exactly one moon be showing?

Two suns add two moons, two moons remove two, and one of each preserves the count. One is odd, so it cannot be reached.

Try one question

Why is one moon impossible under this rule?