Test an always claim with a counterexample
Distinguish an implication from its converse and test universal claims.
The video could not load. Check your connection and try again, or download it directly.
Download video
Open Chinese transcript
- 先看两个说法。能被四整除的正整数,一定是偶数。倒过来说,偶数一定能被四整除吗?
- 第一句,把数分成每组四个。每一组四个,又能拆成两组两个。所以一定能两两配对,没有剩余。
- 有多少组四,就拆出两倍数量的二。这解释了为什么,能被四整除的正整数,一定是偶数。
- 再看倒过来的说法。八是偶数,也能被四整除。但六也是偶数,分成每组四个,还会剩两个。
- 六满足偶数这个前提,却不满足能被四整除。找到这样一个反例,就足够说明第二句,不能说一定。
- 试了几个数都对,还不能证明所有数都对。要说一定,需要能覆盖全部情况的理由。反过来的句子,也得重新检查。
Sources for this explanation
Logical thinking
A counterexample must satisfy the premise while failing the conclusion. Several successful examples do not establish a universal claim.
Worked example
For positive integers, compare every multiple of 4 is even with every even number is a multiple of 4.
4k=2×(2k), so the first is always true. The reverse holds for 8 but fails for the even number 6.
Try one question
6 is even but not divisible by 4, so it meets the premise and fails the conclusion.