Test an always claim with a counterexample

Logical thinking · Suggested grades 5

Distinguish an implication from its converse and test universal claims.

Download video
Open Chinese transcript
  1. 先看两个说法。能被四整除的正整数,一定是偶数。倒过来说,偶数一定能被四整除吗?
  2. 第一句,把数分成每组四个。每一组四个,又能拆成两组两个。所以一定能两两配对,没有剩余。
  3. 有多少组四,就拆出两倍数量的二。这解释了为什么,能被四整除的正整数,一定是偶数。
  4. 再看倒过来的说法。八是偶数,也能被四整除。但六也是偶数,分成每组四个,还会剩两个。
  5. 六满足偶数这个前提,却不满足能被四整除。找到这样一个反例,就足够说明第二句,不能说一定。
  6. 试了几个数都对,还不能证明所有数都对。要说一定,需要能覆盖全部情况的理由。反过来的句子,也得重新检查。
Sources for this explanation

Logical thinking

A counterexample must satisfy the premise while failing the conclusion. Several successful examples do not establish a universal claim.

Worked example

For positive integers, compare every multiple of 4 is even with every even number is a multiple of 4.

4k=2×(2k), so the first is always true. The reverse holds for 8 but fails for the even number 6.

Try one question

Which number disproves every even number is divisible by 4?